“A
NOIR MID-LIFE CRISISâ€
By
Raymond Benson
Fritz
Lang, who emigrated to Hollywood in the 1930s after escaping Nazi Germany,
enjoyed a long and productive career in the U.S. He was, of course, one of
Germany’s preeminent filmmakers in the silent era, having made such dark and
cynical masterpieces as Dr. Mabuse—the Gambler (1922) and Metropolis (1927),
and the brilliant sound picture, M (1931). In Hollywood, Lang was adept
at many genres, but his films noir stand out. His crime pictures are
among the best in this movement that begin in the early 1940s and ran until the
late 1950s.
The
Woman in the Window (1944)
was adapted by Nunnally Johnson from the J. H. Wallis’ novel Once Off Guard.
Johnson made some changes to the original story and added a “surprise†ending.
In 1944 the conclusion may very well have been a clever twist; today it’s a
cliché and a bit of an eye-roller. Nevertheless, there is enough good stuff in Woman
for a worthwhile 99-minutes of viewing.
Some
film noir fans might consider The Woman in the Window to be astonishingly
similar to Lang’s next picture, Scarlet Street (1945). Both movies star
Edward G. Robinson, Joan Bennett, and Dan Duryea, they both begin with the
protagonist being struck by the beauty of a woman’s painting in a shop window,
and the plots involve an older, married man who is infatuated with a younger, perhaps
manipulative femme fatale. The comparisons end there, though. The
unfolding of the stories in each picture are quite different, and The Woman
in the Window ultimately has a much happier wrap-up than Scarlet Street.
Robinson
is Professor Wanley, a respected teacher who frequents a club where he and his
friends, District Attorney Lalor (Raymond Massey) and Dr. Barkstane (Edmund
Breon), enjoy drinks and gossip. Wanley’s wife and children are away. The three
men have all noticed the painting of a beautiful woman in the window of the
shop next door to the club, especially Wanley, and they muse on the woes of
“middle-age†(what we today call a “mid-life crisisâ€). One night, after Lalor
and Barkstane have left the club, Wanley wanders out to the street to gaze at
the painting again. Lo and behold, the model, a young woman named Alice Reed
(Joan Bennett) appears and strikes up a conversation. Wanley is all too
vulnerable to accept an invitation from Alice to see more paintings at her
apartment. While there, another man shows up, is angered by Wanley’s presence,
and the two men get into a fight. Wanley is forced to kill the man in
self-defense. Then things go the way of a Coen Brothers movie if one had been
made in the 40s. Wanley and Reed concoct a rather hairbrained scheme to get rid
of the body and cover up the incident. Enter the dead man’s bodyguard, Heidt
(Dan Duryea), who attempts to blackmail Reed.
There
are twists and turns and even some humor thrown in as Wanley begins to count
all the mistakes he and Reed have made to cover up the crime. The suspense builds
in waiting for the hammer to fall… or does it?
Kino
Lorber’s new Blu-ray release of this unusually rare title is a welcome
acquisition. The restoration looks terrific, and it comes with an audio
commentary by film historian Imogen Sara Smith, along with the trailers for
this and other Kino Lorber releases.
The
Woman in the Window is
a must-have for fans of film noir, director Fritz Lang, and the
charismatic cast members. Edward G. Robinson, especially, seems to have infrequently
received recognition for his professionalism and talent. Recommended.
CLICK HERE TO ORDER FROM AMAZON
