
By Lee Pfeiffer
Until the sexual revolution of the mid-to-late 1960s was embraced by the film industry, the subject of homosexuality was dealt with in schizophrenic manner by studios. There were some bold attempts to address the subject in a serious and sympathetic manner, but fine movies like The Trials of Oscar Wilde and Victim were relegated to art-house hell and never enjoyed a wide audience. Indeed, it was the complete financial failure of the former film that motivated, in desperation, producer Cubby Broccoli to dust off the idea of adapting the James Bond novels for the screen. In other cases, the movies were more high profile (i.e Cat on a Hot Tin Roof, The Children's Hour) but studios forced the directors to substantially water down overt references to homosexuality. Within a few short years, however, the situation had changed dramatically. While many characters were often presented as comical stereotypes, there were other bold attempts to address more realistic approaches to the traumas faced by gays and lesbians. Going one rung further, a few films actually took on such issues as cross-dressing and transsexuals. One of the more notable films of the era was The Christine Jorgensen Story, released in 1970. However, as well-meaning as the movie was, it was generally regarded as an exploitation movie with a good dose of shlock and some unintended laughs. (Click here for review)
Far more impressive was the 1972 British film I Want What I Want...To Be a Woman starring Anne Heywood in a daring performance as an effeminate young man who secretly desires to be a woman. Unlike the real-life Christine Jorgensen, this story is not based on fact, but a novel by writer Geoff Brown. Roy is a sensitive twenty-something man who is living a nightmarish life. He's the son of a macho, ex-army officer (the always brilliant Harry Andrews) who spends most of his time drinking with high society types while he seduces their women. Roy and his father have a fractious relationship as the old man refuses to acknowledge the obvious fact that his son looks more like the daughter he never had. He tries to force Roy into macho behavior by having him escort women on fraudulent dates and making him sit with other men in drawing rooms to argue politics over cigars and brandy. Meanwhile, all Roy wants to do is explore his feminine side. Eventually he can't resist the urge to dress as a woman and is caught in the act by his appalled father, who slaps him around and humiliates him. Distraught, Roy leaves his home to establish a new life in a far away town. This represents his first public appearance as a woman and the film conveys the anxiety cross dressers must feel when they make such a "debut". Although Heywood makes a head-turning woman, we have to remember she's supposed to be a man. As such, she gives a riveting performance and demonstrates the inevitable paranoia that might accompany such a bold lifestyle decision. Roy is convinced that everyone he passes on the street knows his secret.

He ultimately finds refuge as a boarder in a small rooming house where his female alter-ego is embraced by the people around him. He finds their company enjoyable but he is understandably concerned about his secret being unveiled. Roy's goal is to save enough money to get a sex change operation. (The fee to do so, a thousand pounds, sounds laughably low today but in 1972 it was an insurmountable sum for the average Brit.) Roy discovers that his deception and new identity pose a major problem: he can't find work because there is no record of his alter-ego's existence. His problems extend into his non-existent sex life. Although Roy has always denied to himself that he has a sexual attraction to men, this changes when a local lady's man sets his eyes on "her". The resulting psychological battle makes for some riveting moments of drama as Roy debates how to handle the dilemma. After all, how can he pursue a relationship with a man without ultimately disclosing his scandalous secret?
I Want What I Want, ably directed by the little-known John Dexter, is far from a completely satisfying film. One key problem is that, although Roy is supposed to look fragile and effeminate, Heywood is all too-obviously a woman who simply resembles a butch lesbian. One finds it hard to accept her as a young man and her credible performance is somewhat undermined by this flaw. The film also comes to a rather abrupt conclusion that leaves the viewer somewhat frustrated. Nevertheless, the movie is an intelligent look at a person who simply wants to commit the "crime" of being an individual and the unwarranted punishment that is meted out for pursuing that goal. With the issue of transgender rights very much in the news today, this film seems very prescient for the era in which it was made.
The Scorpion DVD label has released the movie, which includes a Spanish language original trailer. Well worth a look.
Click here to order from Amazon